I wonder what Lisa would say today if you interviewed her. Crime scene experts also testified that no evidence of Show writing any initials in her blood was found, and that other evidence discovered at the crime scene did not corroborate Lambert's story.[6]. Here are the families linked to the case. 72: Dying Words (Tabitha Buck - Michelle Lambert - Lawrence Yunkin). In Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, 18-year-old Lisa Michelle Lambert waged a months-long campaign of harassment against 16-year-old Laurie Show in 1991. Buck was granted parole on December 21, 2019. LISA MICHELLE LAMBERT@INSTAGRAM.COM. Lisa Michelle Lambert wrote a tell-all while in prison regarding her version of events entitled "Love, Murder & Corruption in Lancaster County: My Story". All rights reserved (About Us). The phone cord tied around her legs, rope knotted around her neck, and a bloody bread knife lying beside her. Reviewed by Joseph A. Slobodzian. She specializes in the prosecution of child sex offenders, work she finds satisfying. Whitehead and Show also have not heard much about Buck in recent years. Along with that, Lamberts attorneys shared more than two dozen examples of investigative and prosecutorial misconduct. . Laurie Michelle Show was murdered in her home in East Lampeter Twp., Lancaster County on December 20, 1991. Now a 19-year-old, Lambert's daughter is the same age her mother was at the time of Laurie Show's death. Lambert chose to present her case without a jury. On the morning of December 21st, 1991, Hazel Show walked into her apartment to find her 16-year-old daughter Laurie, viciously murdered, her throat slashed and her body assaulted by multiple stab wounds. ABC later featured it on "20/20." The picture at left is Buck's current state prison photo. In 1997, Lamberts appeal went in front of U.S. District Judge Stewart Dalzell. Whitehead rushed up the stairs of the condo. [16], Lambert appealed the 1992 conviction, and in 1997, appeared in court for a federal habeas corpus hearing. He keeps a low profile at his daughter's sporting events, watching their basketball games from the hallway, through a window on a gym door. Yunkin had briefly dated Laurie, during a time he had broken up with Lambert. JN?GrO$>Ji>PAf XG,{&PMB=Yt%.|. ". Instead, as the 10th anniversary of Laurie Show's murder approaches, her family faces Stengel convicted Lambert of first-degree murder. She is buried at the Bridgeville Evangelical Congregational Cemetery in Narvon, Pa. Dec. 17, 2021. "Working with children and giving them a voice, it's very rewarding work and I totally love it," she said. Lisa Michelle Lambert. It was December 19, when Whitehead got a phone call at work. Updated: 12:59 PM EST January 24, 2017. Well written! Whitehead called the police, who said nothing could be done because everyone had left the scene. The photograph at left is of Tabitha Buck when she was arrested for the 1991 murder of Laurie Show. [9] Initial statements from the three claimed that Yunkin had dropped Lambert and Buck off at Show's house, where the two girls murdered Show. Welcome to the TribLIVE.com California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) landing page. Lauries parents are truly brave people and I wish them all the best. 2015-01-13 13:40:17. Investigators said she and Lisa Michelle . It was so senseless, there was absolutely no reason that her life was taken, none what so ever said Whitehead who, with Shows father, agreed to this interview to mark 20 years since the time they lost their daughter. In a book Lambert wrote about the case, she said her familys house sang with life in the days following her release. Greenberg remains retired, she said. Vicki Vellios Briner | Special to PennLiveVicki Vellios Briner | Special to PennLive, When Hazel Show found her daughter on the floor, covered in blood, the last thing she heard was Michelle did it. But problems quickly arose, with prosecutors and the defense suspicious of Yunkins testimony. The one allegation that helped solidify Dalzells opinion on the case came from Hazel Show a few days into the appeal hearing. Rainville said she has never wavered in her belief that Lambert is innocent. Her efforts were successful, with the law being added in 1993. Zl~_jVG|5kR9x,7jsg_%L\84RQ5 `v.0%xxs_^1KB7ByvCz.gzS{> Uz'W`p H`.e@g-Z#/~1+g2\Pe/ E 7w:n`Y6Evpi)Ezf/5$Z'"n~sT {9CFIVA|KT6 uA W_c'4(YoaA m'Y]z3+$hxe#r0Y/.zy*G0 8'C~F>=g ]rI3mw8owsk9#K[mPtfgN_6{[{_b~U4+S >- BPz4\~u/& J)w0%szN27YU_Hw3NlR"4jEbUx{hBs.|qcg"QiByWP8=;WqI+A7t3[*26 She had studied at Santa Monica City College and was employed as the Ranch Manager at St. Bonnie's Animal. LISA MICHELLE LAMBERT@FACEBOOK.COM. Most of all, we must remember the innocent victims, whose lives were taken, have no ability to appeal or receive a new sentence.. [28] A relative of Yunkin provided a poem written by Lambert in jail that described the murder. Lambert also was accused of pushing Laurie into a glass window, which hurt her wrist. The official video for Michelle Lambert - Come to MeDownload or stream here: http://smarturl.it/ComeToMeMLDirected by: Cedric Letsch (https://www.instagram.c. East Lampeter's police chief and a former detective have filed separate lawsuits claiming a book co-authored by convicted killer Lisa Michelle. She had a belief in God and enjoyed Bible study and Sunday school. While understand the police and prosecutors consistently contradicted themselves and their story. I know John and Hazel are, as youve pointed out some facts in here that the media has neglected to share. Buck originally was sentenced to life in prison for the Dec. 20, 1991 murder of 16-year-old Laurie Show in Lancaster Countys Lampeter Township. An autopsy showed that Show's left common carotid artery had been severed. Lisa Lambert is the Founder/CEO, and chairman of UPWARD, a global network of executive women. It's tough and it hurts.". Share to Twitter Share to Facebook. "It was so senseless, there was absolutely no reason that her life was taken, none what so ever" said Whitehead who, with Show's father, agreed to this interview to mark 20 years since the time they lost their daughter. Lisa Michelle Lambert, who was released from New Jersey prison in April 1997 after Federal Judge Stewart Dalzell declared her innocent of murdering Laurie Show, is returned to prison to await . She found Show, lying bloody on the bedroom floor. Her murderer, 19 year-old Lisa Michelle Lambert. Clear & Convincing: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Vs One of those guards was fired and convicted of indecently assaulting her. She believes the case showed how important is the responsibility of a lawyer, and the danger of becoming overzealous in representing a client. Now a 19-year-old, Lambert's daughter is the same age her mother was at the time of Laurie Show's death. She is an electrifying performer as well as a phenomenal songwriter, sultry vocalist and virtuoso violinist. Rainville said she remains in touch with Lambert, and communicated with her as recently as a few weeks ago. Rainville said she did not want to discuss the personal details of Lambert's life. I could see how evil some people can be and how they twist things round to blame the victim. As for the investigators and their misconduct, probes into the Lancaster District Attorneys Office and East Lampeter Township Police Department by the FBI, U.S. Attorneys Office, the state Judicial Conduct Board and Pennsylvania Attorney Generals Office all cleared the authorities that put Lambert away. Police found the trio at a local bowling alley later that day, where they were known to hang out. [12] U.S. District Judge Stewart Dalzell presided over the trial. While on the stand a police officer stated that he never found a pink trash bag which would prove with evidence of Lawrence Yunkin proving he was involved in the crime. [25], Lambert's lawyers presented correspondence between Lambert and Yunkin that they claimed proved that Lambert had not been involved in the murder and that Yunkin had asked her to lie for him. [33], On November 22, 2017, Buck was resentenced to a term of 28 years to life due to a Supreme Court ruling banning mandatory life sentences for juveniles. Yunkin returned to Garden Spot about two years after he left prison and continued bowling there until a fire destroyed the alley this summer. We did not follow the original trial of Lisa Lambert but we did when a federal court judge scathingly criticized her prosecution and released her from prison. Lambert said Buck and Yunkin did the killing. Critical assessment of the film was poor, with one journalist commenting that the film's depiction of both Laurie Show and Lambert distorted the true story. The elements of it - the teenage love triangle, the "lurid allegations" of prosecutorial misconduct - made it a riveting case. It catapulted onto the national stage in the late 1990s, when Lambert appealed her life sentence. Tabitha Buck is 37 and housed at a state prison for women in Muncy in northeastern Pennsylvania, where she has tutored other inmates as she serves out a life sentence that began before she graduated from high school. At the other end of the spectrum, according to people that knew her, was the trash-talking, heavily made up, sometimes violent provocateur, Lisa Michelle Lambert. Lambert had a problem with Show spending time with Yunkin, to the point where Lambert developed a strong hatred towards Show. [21] The third trial took place in May 1998, with a federal appeals court temporarily freeing Lambert under the belief that she would win her case. Want this question answered? Police were involved and charges were pressed for simple assault. Hazel Show told Lambert that Yunkin had raped her daughter Laurie, and that they might press charges if Lambert continued to harass Laurie. No one did anything. Lisa Thomson and Michelle Thomson are a team of Realtor Sisters on The Amazing Race 25. tgdz>q"$1'_zHLc2. LANCASTER - John Show wanted the death penalty for Lisa Michelle Lambert in 1992, after a judge found the woman guilty of murdering his 16-year-old daughter with a butcher knife in a jealous rage over a man. Just before Christmas 1991, Lambert and two accomplices schemed a way to attack and kill Show against whom Lambert had developed an unhealthy resentment. The couple divorced in 2009, local court records show. It was only moments later that Lisa Michelle Lambert and Lamberts friend who also had harassed Show, Tabitha Buck, showed up to the condo on 92 Black Oak Drive. Taylor Goldberg, So nice of you to remember Laurie Show, a young lady who well deserved a fulfilling life, but heartless bullies denied her the opportunity. Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your Privacy Choices and Rights (each updated 1/26/2023). [23], Lambert now testified that Yunkin had participated in the murders, choking Show. She was born July 27, 1958 in San . PennLive file photo Harrisburg . She would tell Laurie that she was ugly and pick on her for having curly hair. Photo courtesy of LancasterOnline. Buck knocked on the door, the two forced their way in and Laurie was killed in a terrible struggle. She noticed that Yunkin and Lambert were parked up front. Upon hearing that a neighbor saw the trio leave her complex, Hazel remembered seeing them herself, driving away. [24] Evidence from the 1997 re-trial was presented again. [22] Judge Lawrence F. Stengel oversaw the trial, he is also Lambert's trial judge from her first trial in 1992. She noticed that Show had been mouthing to Whitehead. If I would have gone to the high school I would have taken Laurie with me. Click here if you wish to opt out and view the full site. `"SD.$Ws|.\Bi>M;s Gt$mS?$~.PE1H~[''|cGx K=3Yyj3k+#4 ^B*4 xxJ> endstream endobj 306 0 obj << /MediaBox [ 0 0 611 791 ] /Resources << /ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ] /Font << /F0 308 0 R >> >> /Contents 307 0 R /Parent 285 0 R /Type /Page /Thumb 187 0 R /CropBox [ 0 0 611 791 ] /Rotate 0 >> endobj 307 0 obj << /Length 1417 /Filter [ /FlateDecode ] >> stream [10] Lambert and Buck would later recant their initial statements, with Lambert claiming that an abusive Yunkin had encouraged her to harass and assault Show. She keeps things to herself, she added. "I don't see me, in my lifetime, at a point where she's not in my present thoughts," she said. If you purchase a product or register for an account through one of the links on our site, we may receive compensation. Lambert attempted to appeal the 1998 decision in 2003 and to bring the case to the Supreme Court of the United States, but was rejected both times. "She's just an exemplary person," Rainville said. Two of the three people convicted of the killing are out of jail due to plea agreements and changes in the law. Show told her mother she had no idea what it could be about, Show did not have gym class. Police said . Find Lisa Lambert's phone number, address, and email on Spokeo, the leading people search directory for contact information and public records. Good luck. In 2019, Buck was paroled after 28 years, at age 46. Lambert's lawyer argued that the institution had done nothing to stop the assaults and that Lambert's conviction would impede her from having a fair trial. I love you.. *g Although the hearing played out over a few more days, Dalzell affirmed his ruling that not only should Lambert be released but that she was innocent of the killing. James Eicher was ordered to spend up to three years in prison, and Lambert was moved to a New Jersey prison as a part of her relief. In separate proceedings, Buck was found guilty and also sentenced to life in prison. A 1992 trial followed, and Lambert chose to have her case heard solely by a judge. Former Penn Manor Principal Jan Mindish recalled Buck coming late to school that day. All rights reserved (About Us). [15] Yunkin received a lesser sentence for his testimony and was granted parole in 2003. District Attorney Craig Stedman, who will become a county judge in January, did not greet the prospect of Bucks release with enthusiasm. Another time, Laurie told her mother that Buck threatened her at the mall. Tabitha Buck testified that she got Laurie to open up the door that day and that she sat on Laurie's legs, while Michelle slit her throat. In the end, Stengel re-convicted Lambert, and although other appeal efforts were made she remains incarcerated today. Our system told victims families their case was over, and in many cases, for decades., The courts ruled and we follow the law, but that in no way diminishes the added emotional trauma this process has caused to those who have already suffered, he said. After 28 years behind bars, Tabitha Buck, a midstate woman who was 17 when she killed a high school classmate is slated for release on Dec. 21. As Show was on her way out, Whitehead said she noticed a girl chasing Show around the mall and then push her into wall. 3,789 records for Lisa Lambert. It was published on February 15, 2016, and can be found on Amazon. "[11], Lambert was convicted on July 20, 1992 of first-degree murder and criminal conspiracy in the death of Show. (Page 4) An only child, he is the last of his immediate family. Whitehead said she receives an occasional restitution payment from Yunkin. The Piano fans claim show is 'the best thing they've seen' after George, 94, performing for Claudia Winkleman leaves them 'crying for an hour' - as presenter confirms The Traitors return Michelle Lambert is a genre-defying 21st century talent with a lot on her mind!". Allida is tongue-tied with An Impossible Thing to Say by Arya Shahi, in which an Iranian American teen in Arizonafalls in love with the new girl at school, Shakespeare, and rap music while . The film was directed by Norma Bailey and starred Jennifer Finnigan as Laurie Show. The one who fought the hardest, and loudest, is still sitting in a cell. As Laurie leaned a little bit further over, Tabitha saw her reach for a pair of scissors and knocked them out her reach. Days later, at Lancasters local Market, Roots, Lambert and Yunkin followed Show and her mother. She cut the rope from Lauries neck and noticed her neck was cut. The woman, 47, snapped after the 11-year-old started hitting her . 1: With Lanie Hobbs. "I remember the high level of emotion," said Stengel, now a U.S. District Court judge who has offices in Philadelphia and Reading. For such a violent crime against Laurie Show, all three suspects should've had defensive wounds but Lisa Lambert had none. Life marched on for Show's parents, John Show and Hazel Whitehead, who lost their only daughter on Dec. 20, 1991. "You have to do your best to continue to do what you can to make your life better and to help others. I love you.. In November Show and some friends went shopping at East Town Mall. This has severely hindered her from seeing . Not too long after they met, Lambert starting giving Show a hard time concerning her appearance. The couple divorced in 2009, local court records show. He enjoys his godchildren but thinks about the grandchildren he never will have. In his lengthy written opinion, he pointed to 25 instances of misconduct, which Lamberts defense said was only a small fraction of what really happened. By December, it turned deadly. " "Girl On Fire, Michelle Lambert, makes . Lisa Michelle Lambert was sentenced 22 years ago to life without parole for slashing the throat of 16-year-old Laurie Show at the victim's East Lampeter Township home. Buck said Lambert sliced Laurie's throat. The case is perhaps the county's best-known murder case. It was not too long after that the two approached Show and her mother and caused yet another scene, Whitehead and Show were able to find a constable at the market to end the confrontation. When she asked what happened, Buck said that she had gone to McDonalds before school and got into a fist fight with a Hispanic girl. Lisa Michelle Lambert is the author of Love, Murder, and Corruption in Lancaster County (3.58 avg rating, 19 ratings, 5 reviews) When she told this to the lead investigator at the time, he told her not to dwell on the sighting, and it was forgotten, she testified. Support local journalism. Exonerated in 1997. Lambert slit the young woman's throat and killed her in a fit of jealous rage, while Buck sat on Laurie's legs. They hung out together. I hope this young girls death (horrid as it was) was not in vain and that we all can learn from this. Yunkin claimed he didnt realize the gravity of what happened. [17], A huge amount of Evidence provided at the hearing included the sweatpants entered into the 1992 proceeding as well as correspondence between Yunkin and Lambert where Yunkin admits in his own handwriting that he and Tabitha Buck killed Laurie Show and asked Lambert to take blame for him, because she'll get less time because she is a female. Her mother Hazel Show had driven to an early morning meeting that turned out to be a prank and returned to discover her daughter laying on the floor in her bedroom. I cant imagine what it would be like to find your only child dying, her life snuffed out by a brutal killer. Jack and Lisa Lambert are raising their kids on a 125-acre plot in the rural outpost of Worthington (population: 763), seven miles west of Kittanning. X (clh)%^9$=u#Esxj91u?`[(eZ\Ggg(MTsanmyAz_ ?esB@+`X. Approximately 36 hours after the murder, Lambert, Buck and Yunkin were all arrested at the Garden Spot Bowling Alley in Strasburg. Buck winces as she recalls the event. Lisa Lambert in Maryland. Now 48 and living in Bennington County in southern Vermont, Rainville said the Lambert case still deeply disturbs her, as does the fact that Lambert remains in prison. ". The detectives testimony denied allegations that evidence had been tampered with. It keeps him occupied and busy. Both John Show and Whitehead agreed that talking about their daughter is how they cope with the pain of losing her. According to Mindish everyone was on Christmas break when the story of the Laurie Show murder hit the news and only several employees were still to work at the school. Hazel Whitehead left her home 20 years ago today for what she thought was an appointment with her daughter's guidance counselor at school. Lisa Ann Lambert, 61, of Dubuque, Iowa, passed away on December 28, 2022, at home. She is buried at the Bridgeville Evangelical Congregational Cemetery in Narvon, Pa. Dec. 17, 2021. Her parents, Leonard and Judy, obtained custody of the child. No one to walk down the aisle. Today, he'll carry a single rose to the cemetery where his daughter is buried. Shows mother found her dying daughter, who was able to identify her killers. She feels comfortable as a prosecutor in Vermont, where she said the procedural rules are different from Pennsylvania's. CALGARY - The mother of Lisa Michelle Mitchell is speaking about her loss, days after police confirmed her daughter was murdered. Laurie Show was a 16-year-old sophomore at Conestoga Valley High School who was stalked by her classmates and murdered on December 20, 1991, in the United States. Whitehead knew something was wrong, so she rushed home. In pastoral central Pennsylvania, nobody knew what to do with Lisa Michelle Lambert. Much of her story contradicts the testimony and evidence that was used against her at trial. Thanks for sharing. Although there were no charges filed against the police officers who investigated the case, Lamberts allegations of misconduct and framing ended up carrying a lot of weight with one judge. The convicted killer earned a college degree behind bars, where she has spent almost all of her adult life, save for a 10-month period of freedom. For Hazel Whitehead and John Show, the life that has been lost is that of their only child. More Local News to Love Start today for 50% off Expires 3/6/23. Dateline 2017 Lisa Michelle Lambert The Murder of Laurie Show NBC Dateline Mysteries. [36], In 2000, the murder was adapted into a TV film entitled The Stalking of Laurie Show (also known by the title Rivals outside of the US). They were scared, said Whitehead. Both Spangler and the attendance officer had to later testify in court. Both of Lamberts co-defendants are out of jail. YouTubes privacy policy is available here and YouTubes terms of service is available here. Hazel testified that at some point Yunkin date-raped Laurie, and the relationship ended. [32], In 2007 Lambert appeared in court to sue the correctional institution over claims that she was raped and assaulted by state prison staff in 1996. At another store, Lambert and a group of friends reportedly approached Laurie and threatened her in front of her mother. UPWARD is a non-profit organization with 16 chapters, over 60 corporate sponsors, and over 6000 members worldwide. The passion and severity behind the stalking offer a stark contrast to how Lambert later described her relationship with Yunkin. Judge Stewart Stengel did not allow all the evidence from the 1997 hearing in judge dalzell court room to come in during this hearing. A federal judge agreed, briefly freeing Lambert from prison in a move that stunned many here. The Lancaster DAs office had attempted to bar her from filing any more appeals at that time. Different judges hearing the case felt differently about the appeals. This was presented to Lancaster County Judge Lawrence Stengel during a trial by judge, after Lambert specifically requested to handle her case without a jury. Lambert's lawyers claimed there were several inconsistencies with the evidence and testimony given in the earlier trial, and that Lambert was innocent. Her daughter's photos remain in her house. In a 1996 lawsuit, Lisa Michelle Lambert, 34, accused . On appeal, Lambert said she was being abused by Yunkin, both physically and emotionally. Yunkin was ordered to hold the sweatpants up against his body, which were shown to be too short for him, as well as being made of a different fabric from the garment entered into evidence in the 1992 trial. The next morning, Dec. 20, Whitehead left for the meeting. Show had been doing her hair when she left. She alleged prosecutors tampered with evidence to frame her for the murder so they could silence her about an alleged gang rape by police, a charge later rejected by the court. Lambert wasnt a juvenile when the murder occurred and so is serving a life prison term without parole, although she continues to fight her conviction. He changed his story from saying he only dropped the girls off and didnt know what was going to happen to admitting that he knew they wanted to beat up Show. A video tape was shown of this officer on the stand finding the pink trash bag with the evidence. I don't know if I've totally figured out what it is, but I'll keep working at it.". But the justice system has already determined that two of the three have paid their debts to society. If you are using Chrome and keep getting redirected to this page, then turn sync off. Yunkin took a plea agreement to third-degree murder, a more serious charge than he was originally offered due to changing his story. She testified that Yunkin raped her daughter, and learned Michelle was pregnant shortly after. There is not a day that goes by that I dont talk about her in someway, said Whitehead. Once the trio started making statements to the police, the picture of what happened became clear, except for Yunkins role. She then ended up in Stengel's courtroom again as he presided over a hearing in her case that drew national attention with its wide-ranging and often bizarre accusations of prosecutorial misconduct.